Talking about film the other night with a custodian in my school, he asked “So what’s your favorite film noir?” Not wanting to disappoint, I searched my increasingly aging mind and, of course, hedged. Luckily I had a copy of “The World’s Most Overly-Used Cliches” handy and was able to respond with, “Well, you know there are so many that it’s hard to pick just one.”
Nevertheless, here’s one to consider with a good plot summary of the film from its Wikipedia site (CAUTION: SPOILER ALERT )
The Woman in the Window (1944) starring Edward G. Robinson, Joan Bennett, Raymond Massey, and Dan Duryea
“After criminology professor Richard Wanley sends his wife and two children off on vacation, he goes to his club to meet friends. Next door, Wanley sees a striking oil portrait of Alice Reed (Joan Bennett) in a storefront window. He and his friends talk about the beautiful painting and its subject. Wanley stays at the club and reads Song of Songs. When he leaves, Wanley stops at the portrait and meets Reed, who is standing near the painting watching people watch it. Reed convinces Wanley to join her for drinks.
Later, they go to Reed’s home, but an unexpected visit from her rich lover Claude Mazard (Arthur Loft) leads to a fight in which Wanley kills Mazard. Wanley and Reed conspire to cover up the murder, and Wanley disposes Mazard’s body in the country. However, Wanley leaves many clues, and there are a number of witnesses. One of Wanley’s friends from the club, district attorney Frank Lalor (Raymond Massey) has knowledge of the investigation, and Wanley is invited back to the crime scene, as Lalor’s friend, but not as a suspect. There are several comic dialogues in which Wanley appears to know more about the murder than he should. As the police gather more evidence, Reed is blackmailed by Heidt (Dan Duryea), a crooked ex-cop who was Mazard’s bodyguard. Reed attempts to poison Heidt with a prescription overdose when he returns the next day, but Heidt is suspicious and takes the money without drinking the drugs. Reed tells Wanley, who overdoses on the remaining prescription medicine.
Heidt is killed in a shootout immediately after leaving Reed’s home, and police believe Heidt is Mazard’s murderer. Reed, seeing that the police have killed Heidt, races to her home to call Wanley, who is slumped over in his chair, and apparently he dies. In an impossible match on action, Wanley awakens in his chair at his club, and he realizes the entire adventure was a dream in which employees from the club were main characters in the dream. As he steps out on the street in front of the painting, a woman asks Wanley for a light. He adamantly refuses and runs down the street.”
As for my own thoughts, this was one of the first films I watched after my nior baptismal. It’s held a special place for me for a number of other reasons too.
For one, Edward G. Robinson’s character is not one I would have previously associated with his acting career. As a kid, my opinions of Robinson had been shaped by the characterizations of him as a cigar-chomping cartoon character from Looney Tunes and Courageous Cat episodes. As an every man of sorts caught up like future Hithcockian protagonists , I could relate to his plight and sympathize with his character.
Additionally, the role of the femme fatale was played to perfection by the lovely Joan Bennett. I was stricken by how risque her dialogue, costumes, and actions were in the film. Anyone thinking that old films play as prudish by today’s standards (or lack of) need only watch Bennett’s portrayal here.
Finally, The Woman in the Window carries with it a sense of redemption missing (and with good reason) from most noirs. Fortunately it pulls it off without feeling forced or heavy-handed. Not an easy task to accomplish. This is a not only a highly recommended film noir held in high regard by fans of the genre, but also one that’s easily accessible to all.
Click the link to watch The Woman in the Window (1944- Directed by Friz Lang)